The regular season is over and it’s the perfect time to consider the MVP and Cy Young winners. The Red Sox have some good candidates. The Red Sox have several MVP candidates starting with Mookie Betts who showed he is an all around 5-tool player. David Ortiz in his final season performed better than any player in his final season is also considered a frontrunner for the AL MVP. Rick Porcello is my top choice to win the Cy Young. He’s 22-4 with a 3.11 ERA!
The Sox have a good chance to have both the AL MVP and AL Cy Young winners this year, I decided to do some research on the MVP and Cy Young award winners. How many teams had both the MVP and Cy Young award winners and what happened to their teams? Read on to find out.
The “Baseball Bits”
- Since 1956 when the Cy Young award began (it was split into 2 awards (AL and NL) in 1967), 28 teams have had an MVP and Cy Young winner in the same year (MVP/Cy Young pair)
- From 1956 to 1966, there were 7 teams that had MVP/Cy Young pair in the same year
- The last team to do it was the 2014 Dodgers (Clayton Kershaw won both awards)
- 8 of the teams who had MVP/Cy Young pair in the same year had pitchers who won both
- The last team to have different players who won MVP/Cy Young in the same year was the 2013 Tigers
- 15 of the 28 Cy Young/MVP pairs came from the AL
- The Red Sox only had a Cy Young and MVP Winner twice: in 1967 (Carl Yastrzemski & Jim Lonborg) and 1986 (Roger Clemens won both awards). The Sox lost the World Series in both of those years
- The Indians and Blue Jays, who could also achieve this in 2016, have never done it before
- The Cubs, who are also candidates have done it once (1984, Ryne Sandberg & Rick Sutcliffe). They lost in the NLCS.
- Only one team who had an MVP/Cy Young pair in the same year missed the playoffs (the 1962 Dodgers)
- 16 of the 27 (59%) who made the playoffs made the World Series, and 8 of the 16 teams won the World Series
- 23 of the 27 teams (85%) made it past the ALDS/NLDS
One thing that this research proved is that MVP and Cy Young voters place value on players from playoff teams. It’s not common (especially since 1968) for a team to have an MVP/Cy Young pair but it’s even less common to have that team not make the playoffs. This year the Sox made the playoffs by winning the division so I think it increases the Red Sox’s chances to have their third MVP/Cy Young pair, especially since they dominated down the stretch to pull away from the pack.
Below are my picks for who wins the AL and NL MVP and Cy Young:
AL MVP Prediction: Mookie Betts
Mookie Betts has been on fire this year and the fact that he’s a 5 tool player just makes him more worthy of the award. Betts and the Red Sox lineup have just been really impressive this year. I also think even though guys like Mike Trout and Miguel Cabrera would be good candidates, that the MVP and Cy Young should come from a playoff team and my research shows that voters do as well. Betts is one of the best of this great Red Sox lineup and the Red Sox have been one of the best offensive teams in the league. Betts has not only been a top offensive player but his defensive statistics show he’s a top gold glove candidate as well. Big Papi may be a candidate too since it’s his last season but if voters focus purely on overall numbers, their vote will be for Betts.
AL Cy Young Prediction: Rick Porcello
I really don’t think there are many good options besides Rick Porcello. Corey Kluber could compete with him but I’m giving Porcello the edge. Kluber has won before and was expected to do well this year. He just won in 2014! On the other hand, Rick Porcello was not expected to that well this year. Instead, he’s top 5 in every key pitching category and first in wins so I don’t know how he does not win. The fact that Porcello along with Hanley Ramirez, have had such great second seasons unexpectedly, vindicates Ben Cherington a bit.
NL MVP Prediction: Anthony Rizzo
Nolan Arenado would be a better candidate if team performance did not matter. But have the Rockies done anything this season? I was thinking of making an exception to picking MVPs and Cy Youngs from just playoff teams but there are other candidates that come from the 102-58 Chicago Cubs. Anthony Rizzo and Kris Bryant would also make good candidates. I picked Rizzo because he had a better average and more RBIs despite less home runs.
NL Cy Young Prediction: Max Scherzer
There are a lot of good NL pitchers that are worthy of this award. But if anyone has proven all around excellence in pitching, it’s Max Scherzer. Scherzer was a candidate last year but didn’t quite make it to the final 3 despite 2 no-hitters (1 that was almost a perfect game). This year his ERA is good again (2.82) and he has a huge lead in strikeouts (277). He also has an unbelieveable WHIP (0.94), and leads the NL in wins tied with Jon Lester. All of those stats are Cy Young worthy.
The Red Sox actually have a pretty good chance of an MVP/Cy Young pair. I don’t see many players who can beat out Rick Porcello and the Sox have such a good lineup that I’m more than 50% sure a Red Sox player will win the MVP. The chances are looking good but the winners would need to be really good because this has only happened 28 times. Are the Red Sox a realistic candidate? We’ll find out soon and hopefully that means they also have a good chance to win it all.